All articles

Practical guide

Should We Get Married? The Different Logics Behind Premarital Discernment

Discernment, an officiant's view, a score, the couple's introspection

6 minutes·13 October 2026

Key takeaways

• Several traditions and methods build in a moment where someone can conclude it isn't the right time: spiritual discernment, a religious officiant's view, a score from a validated assessment, or the couple's own introspection.

• A UCLA study (Lavner, Karney & Bradbury, 2012) followed 464 newlyweds: premarital doubts reported by wives were linked to more than double the risk of divorce within four years.

• None of these mechanisms is meant to decide for the couple: they flag, they don't order.

• A real, deep-seated doubt belongs with a qualified person (a religious counselor, a couples therapist), never with an online quiz alone.

What the "go/no-go" thread means

None of the marriage-preparation paths covered in this series — Catholic, Protestant, Orthodox, Jewish, Islamic, or the professional assessments — exists only to organize a ceremony. Each one, in its own way, leaves room for the couple or a third party to notice they aren't ready, or that something still needs resolving before moving forward. This page compares these logics without ranking them: they answer different needs and rest on different kinds of legitimacy.

Four logics, four kinds of legitimacy

Spiritual discernment

In several religious traditions, marriage preparation includes a period of discernment: the couple is invited to check, in light of their faith, that their plan matches what the commitment implies (fidelity, permanence, children, the sacred dimension of the union as that tradition understands it). This discernment is carried by the couple itself, often with the support of a guide — a priest, pastor, or mentor couple. It's a matter of conscience, not a score: there's generally no numeric result, just a gradual clarifying over the course of the preparation meetings.

A religious officiant's view

In some traditions, an officiant (a Catholic priest, rabbi, imam, or pastor depending on the church) may, after the preparation meetings, voice a concern or ask for more time before the ceremony — practices vary a great deal by denomination, local community and country, and the officiant involved is the right person to ask what applies in a specific case. This view isn't an outside verdict imposed against the couple's will: it sits within an ongoing conversation, and in general the couple remains the one deciding what happens next, within whatever framework that tradition sets.

The score from a validated assessment

Tools like PREPARE/ENRICH, FOCCUS or SYMBIS (see our dedicated page on the PREPARE/ENRICH, FOCCUS and SYMBIS assessments) produce a result based on each partner's self-reported answers, across categories like communication, conflict management or finances. That result flags areas of divergence or statistical risk, which is then walked through and discussed with a trained facilitator. This is a measurement logic: it makes gaps between partners visible, but it doesn't predict failure, and it should never replace the couple's direct conversation with the facilitator.

The couple's own introspection

The fourth logic doesn't run through any institution at all: it's the couple who, by talking to each other, preparing for the wedding, or simply living through the day-to-day of planning, becomes aware of a deep disagreement, a fear, or an incompatibility they hadn't named before. This is often the hardest to make objective, since it rests entirely on each person's honesty with themselves and with their partner, with no third party to validate or temper it.

What the research on premarital doubts shows

A study published in 2012 in the Journal of Family Psychology by Justin A. Lavner, Benjamin R. Karney and Thomas N. Bradbury (University of California, Los Angeles) followed 464 newlywed spouses (232 couples) in Los Angeles, interviewed separately in the first months of marriage and then every six months for four years. About 47% of husbands and 38% of wives reported having had doubts before their wedding. Among wives who reported doubts, the four-year divorce rate was 19%, versus 8% among those who hadn't — a risk more than doubled, which remained significant after controlling for factors like parental divorce or premarital cohabitation. Among husbands, the gap (14% versus 9%) wasn't statistically significant. Among couples who stayed married, those who had reported doubts showed lower average marital satisfaction four years later.

This study doesn't say that having doubts dooms a marriage: the large majority of people who reported doubts didn't divorce within four years. What it suggests is that a doubt taken seriously and named out loud is worth exploring rather than ignoring — which is exactly the spirit behind the four logics described above.

Comparison table

• Spiritual discernment — Who holds the decision: The couple, in conscience · Basis: Teaching of the tradition · Nature of the signal: Gradual, not scored

• Officiant's view — Who holds the decision: Shared between couple and officiant · Basis: Preparation meetings · Nature of the signal: Concern or recommendation

• Validated assessment score — Who holds the decision: The couple, informed by the facilitator · Basis: Self-reported answers, measured categories · Nature of the signal: Risk or divergence score

• Couple's introspection — Who holds the decision: The couple alone · Basis: Daily life, internal dialogue · Nature of the signal: Unstructured realization

In practice: who to talk to

If a serious doubt surfaces — about fidelity, children, money, or a more diffuse sense of not being ready — the right people to talk to are the same regardless of which logic brought the doubt to the surface: the religious counselor involved in preparation, a licensed couples therapist or counselor, or a trusted person outside the relationship who can listen without judgment. In no case should an online personality quiz be the one to settle a decision of this magnitude: a quiz can help you name a feeling or open a conversation, not decide for the couple.

Limits worth knowing

None of these four logics produces certainty. Spiritual discernment depends on each person's faith; an officiant's view remains an opinion, not an objective fact; an assessment score measures self-reported answers at one point in time, not the future; a couple's introspection can be skewed by the social or logistical pressure of preparations already underway. This page never suggests that a couple "should" break up or call off a wedding: it describes mechanisms that exist, and what they're meant to surface.

If you're not religious or not practicing

The spiritual-discernment and officiant's-view logics naturally apply only to couples going through a faith-based preparation process. A non-religious couple still has the other two available: a validated assessment administered by a licensed counselor (see our page on PREPARE/ENRICH, FOCCUS and SYMBIS), or structured introspection using our premarital conversation kit.

FAQ

Does having doubts before the wedding mean we should call it off?

No. Research shows a substantial share of married people report having had doubts, and most don't divorce. A doubt deserves to be explored, not automatically acted on.

Who has the final say: the religious officiant or the couple?

That depends heavily on the tradition and local community. In most cases the officiant guides the process and can voice a concern, but the decision largely stays with the couple, within the framework each denomination sets.

Can an online test tell me whether I should get married?

No, and no serious tool claims to. A personality test can help you name a trait or a pattern, not settle a decision this personal.

Further reading

• PREPARE/ENRICH, FOCCUS, SYMBIS: the validated premarital assessments

• Marriage preparation paths compared

• Premarital conversations: a topic-by-topic question kit

References

• Lavner, J. A., Karney, B. R., & Bradbury, T. N. (2012). Do cold feet warn of trouble ahead? Premarital uncertainty and four-year marital outcomes. Journal of Family Psychology, 26(6). DOI: 10.1037/a0029912. Associated press release: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2012/09/120913173324.htm

Take the attachment style test

Discover your attachment style with the Polaris test.

Take the attachment style test

Go deeper

Related rituals

Les contenus Polaris sont proposés à des fins de divertissement et de développement personnel uniquement. Ils ne constituent en aucun cas un avis médical, psychologique, juridique ou financier. Pour toute décision importante, consultez un professionnel qualifié.

Polaris n'utilise aucune marque déposée : nos tests sont des tests originaux, simplement inspirés de modèles connus (MBTI®, Ennéagramme, DISC, Big Five, Human Design, 5 langages de l'amour…). Ils ne sont ni affiliés ni validés par leurs détenteurs. Pour passer les tests officiels, rendez-vous directement sur les sites dédiés.